Compare the positions, not just the subject
Summarize each author's main claim separately before comparing them. Distinguish disagreement about a conclusion from disagreement about how strongly the evidence supports it. An author can accept the data while questioning the proposed explanation.
- A sentence may introduce, define, contrast, illustrate, concede, or conclude.
- Purpose answers should be tied to the author's goal.
- Cross-text questions ask how two authors relate, not which one you prefer.
- Tone can reveal whether the author is cautious, critical, enthusiastic, or neutral.
- A detail can support a claim without being the main claim.
Agreement on the finding, disagreement on the cause
Text 1 says a city's new bike lanes caused a rise in cycling. Text 2 accepts that cycling rose but notes that fuel prices increased during the same period. How would Text 2 respond to Text 1?
Text 2 would question whether the bike lanes alone explain the increase. It does not deny the observed rise in cycling or prove fuel prices were the sole cause. The disagreement concerns causal attribution, not whether the measured change occurred.
Map the agreement before the disagreement
| Issue | Text 1 | Text 2 |
|---|---|---|
| Did cycling increase? | Yes | Yes |
| Did bike lanes alone cause it? | Claims a causal link | Raises an alternative explanation |
Use the method while it is fresh.
What to eliminate in the answer choices
- Choosing a topic answer when the question asks for function.
- Missing a cautious tone.
- Treating partial disagreement as complete rejection.
What is a common comparison trap?
Turning a limited qualification into total rejection. If one author asks for more evidence, do not paraphrase that position as declaring the other author wrong on every point.